The 1991 Topps Wayne Gretzky #258 is valued at $1.88 raw, $17.50 in PSA 9, $43.39 in PSA 10 as of October 15, 2026. With 23 recorded sales, it ranks #363 of 500 hockey cards we track by trading volume.
On current values, a PSA 9 ($17.50) is worth $9.38 less than a raw copy plus a $25.00 grading fee, while a PSA 10 ($43.39, 23.1× raw) is worth $16.51 more, so the difference comes down to the grade.
About $1.88 raw, $17.50 in PSA 9, $43.39 in PSA 10, based on our market values as of October 15, 2026.
On current values, a PSA 9 ($17.50) is worth $9.38 less than a raw copy plus a $25.00 grading fee, while a PSA 10 ($43.39, 23.1× raw) is worth $16.51 more, so the difference comes down to the grade. This ignores gem rate and selling fees, so treat it as a best case.